ETIOLOGY AND RISK FACTORS
The exact cause of suicidal behavior is unknown, but it is clear that the etiology is multifactorial (Zalsman, 2019). Studies done to date have found that suicide is most often caused by a collection of risk factors and underlying vulnerabilities. Genetic predisposition is a part of the explanation, but other biological, social, economic, lifestyle, and environmental factors also play important roles in the etiology of suicidal behavior. Mental illness is a major factor in the development of suicidal behavior (Strawbridge, 2019).
Biologic Factors
Biologic factors that contribute to suicide include a person’s genetic predisposition and personality traits, neurobiology, structural brain changes, immune system dysregulation, neuropsychology, and psychopathology.
GENETIC PREDISPOSITION
The risk of suicide increases in patients who have a family history of suicide. Studies have shown that if one sibling dies by suicide, the risk of remaining siblings for dying by suicide is increased among both men and women. Studies have also shown that if an identical twin attempted suicide, their co-twin has a 17.5% increased risk of having made an attempt, and if an identical twin dies by suicide, the co-twin has an 11.3% increased risk of dying by suicide as well (Reiss & Dombeck, 2019a).
Twin studies also indicate that those patients with a family history of suicide most likely have both genetic as well as environmental components, and the risk of inheriting suicidal traits is in the range of 30% to 50%. It is unclear, however, whether or not the genetic component is primarily responsible for an underlying psychiatric disorder or the suicide itself.
It is also known that having an unrelated spouse who has a psychiatric disorder or who dies by suicide increases the risk of suicide by the surviving spouse, showing the importance of environmental effects within the family structure (Schreiber & Culpepper, 2019).
It is not quite clear which genes are related to suicide. Many suggest there is not a specific gene (or set of genes) that increase someone’s risk for suicide, but rather what is being transmitted is the likelihood of developing specific types of mental illness that can increase the risk of suicide (Reiss & Dombeck, 2019a).
NEUROBIOLOGY
Suicide is the result of a complex set of factors reflected in the neurobiology of the suicidal individual. Data indicate that mental disorders are present in over 90% of suicides in our society, and many of them are associated with biological changes. However, there are many other factors that correlate with suicidality that also have biological aspects, including predisposing personality traits, effects of acute and chronic stress, gender, and age (NAS, 2019).
Suicidal adults and adolescents tend to display certain temperaments attributed to the neurobiology of the brain. Two in particular are thought to be related to suicidal behavior. The first is referred to as a depressive/withdrawn temperament and the other as impulsive/aggressive.
Individuals with depressive/withdrawn temperaments show high levels of negative mood, have difficulty controlling their moods, and tend to overreact to daily stressors. They are more likely to develop depression and anxiety. In addition, many of these individuals often have histories of being abused or developing inadequate relationships with caregivers.
People with impulsive/aggressive temperaments also have difficulty controlling their emotions, particularly anger. They are more likely to die by suicide even without having a mood disorder and are often diagnosed with antisocial personality disorder. Impulsive/aggressive individuals are sensation seekers and often engage in risky behaviors, make poor or snap judgments, and abuse alcohol and/or other substances. Children with this temperament type often have a history of abuse, in particular sexual abuse.
Research suggests that a person’s temperament type is related to genes that control regulation in the brain and nervous system of the neurotransmitters serotonin and norepinephrine, which influence control of our moods (Reiss & Dombeck, 2019a).
Serotonin and Epinephrine
Reduced serotonergic neurotransmission has been a long-standing hypothesis in the etiology of suicide and mood disorders, and evidence suggests that serotonin mediates inhibition of impulsive action. Low levels of the serotonin metabolite 5-HIAA are detectable in the brains of those who died from suicide and in the cerebrospinal fluid of those who attempted suicide but did not die. Abnormalities in the serotonin system are more pronounced with more lethal suicidal behavior, and levels in the CSF are a strong correlate of current and future suicidal behavior (Underwood et al., 2018: NAS, 2019).
Suicidal individuals also appear to have lower levels of norepinephrine, also called noradrenaline, in the part of the brain called the locus ceruleus. Norepinephrine participates in modulation of numerous behaviors (including stress response) and promotes formation of and strengthens memories, especially those created in stress situations. It has profound effects on a small set of behaviors, including those that are commonly disrupted in depression. Norepinephrine dysfunction may indirectly contribute to suicide through negative effects on mood (Khroud & Saadabadj, 2019).
Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenal Axis
The hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis is a system tying together the hypothalamus and the pituitary gland with the adrenal glands. It controls the body’s responses to actual, anticipated, or perceived harm. It also controls the ability to adapt to stressors over time. Dysregulation of the HPA axis in vulnerable people can lead them to develop severe depression, severe anxiety disorders, and suicidal behavior following traumatic events or chronic stress.
In response to stress, the HPA axis produces glucose, cortisol, and steroids. Autopsy studies show that people who die by suicide have elevated cortisol levels and enlarged adrenal glands, suggesting their bodies were experiencing extreme stress. Exactly how the HPA axis influences suicidal behavior is not yet clear, but researchers believe that increased cortisol levels affect the mood-regulating neurotransmitter serotonin, making it hard for serotonin to get to the brain and nervous system receptors (Reiss & Dombeck, 2019a; NAS, 2019).
STRUCTURAL CHANGES IN THE BRAIN
From brain scans, researchers have found there are significant differences in the volume of gray matter between people who have attempted suicide and those who have not. Those who attempted suicide had less gray matter in regions related to emotional regulation, emotional response, and memory. They also had a decreased amount of white matter connecting brain areas that are involved in these functions. Most volumetric MRI studies have shown smaller gray matter volumes mostly in the frontal and temporal cortical regions, the corpus callosum, and insula in persons with suicidal behavior with different psychiatric diagnoses. Structural changes within the frontostriatal pathway may result in an impaired control of behavior and emotion, leading to suicidal behavior (Balcioglu & Kose, 2018).
INFLAMMATION
Mounting evidence implicates dysregulation of the immune system in the pathophysiology of suicidality, suggesting that inflammation is involved in suicidal behavior. Using positron emission tomography, participants’ brains were scanned and signs of inflammation were found to be present in those persons with depression experiencing suicidal thoughts. They were found to have significantly higher levels of translocator protein (TSPO) than in those who were not experiencing suicidal thoughts. TSPO plays a role in the immune response system and cell death. In the brain, elevated TSPO activates the microglia, which are immune cells specific to the brain. Microglial activation indicates brain inflammation, strengthening the suggestion that inflammation is linked specifically with suicidal ideation.
Where inflammation of the brain was noted, it was usually in the anterior cingulate cortex, which is involved with cognition and emotional responses. Signs of inflammation were also noted to a smaller degree in the insular cortex, which plays a role in regulating emotional function, and in the prefrontal cortex, implicated in cognitive processes related to behavior (Holmes et al., 2018; Brundin et al, 2017).
NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL DEFICITS
Neuropsychological deficits can develop during the prenatal, perinatal, and postnatal periods of life. Prenatal causes may include genetic or chromosomal disorders, metabolic conditions, brain malformations, or maternal disease. Perinatal causes may involve events during labor and delivery leading to encephalopathy. Postnatal causes may include hypoxic ischemic injury, infections, traumatic brain injury, and severe and chronic social deprivation, among others (Schofield, 2018).
Deficits in cognitive processing and neurological activity have been found in suicidal persons that are specifically related to executive function (cognitive control), which allows for planning and executing goal-directed behavior including the ability to regulate emotions, exert inhibitory control, shift focus between multiple tasks, and flexibly modify behavior according to a situation.
Deficits relate to impairment of a broad range of cognitive functions such as long-term memory and working memory, attention, problem-solving, and decision-making. Executive dysfunction is said to have a direct impact on emotional regulation, preventing individuals from engaging in effective mood-regulating strategies, and has also been linked to a reduced ability to deal with the emotional disturbances commonly present in suicidal individuals (Thompson & Ong, 2018).
PSYCHOPATHOLOGY
Psychiatric diseases account for a large majority of suicides and suicide attempts—at least 10 times as high as in the general population. Psychological autopsies (collected from family relatives, friends, and healthcare providers) from the middle of the previous century and onward have revealed that most (at least 90%) of those who have died by suicide were experiencing a mental disorder, the relevant risk factors being depression, substance use disorders, and psychosis. However, anxiety-, personality-, eating-, and trauma-related disorders, as well as organic mental disorders such as dementia or physical illness, also contribute to risk (Brådvik, 2018; Bachmann, 2018).
Anxiety disorders more than double the risk of suicide attempts, and a combination of depression and anxiety greatly increases the risk. Symptoms of psychosis (delusions, command auditory hallucinations, paranoia) may increase the risk regardless of the specific diagnosis (Schreiber & Culpepper, 2019).
Differences have also been found between inpatients and outpatients treated for mental illness. Inpatient suicides (45%) were preceded by schizophrenia and organic mental disorders. Outpatient suicides (32%) occurred in those with depression; substance use; and somatoform, anxiety, and adjustment disorders. It has been suggested that inpatient status by itself may be a risk factor, as the lifetime suicide risk is much higher than in never-hospitalized outpatients (Bachmann, 2018).
It has been found that 41% of those who died by suicide had been psychiatric inpatients within the previous year, and as many as 9% of suicides occurred within one day of discharge from psychiatric inpatient care (Schreiber & Culpepper, 2019).
One in four active duty members of the U.S. military exhibit symptoms of mental illness, which are mostly the manifestation of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression, traumatic brain injury, and/or stress related to transition back to civilian life. The lifetime prevalence of depression and PTSD is 5 to 15 times higher respectively when compared to civilians (Shirol & Current, 2019).
Psycho-Sociocultural Factors
Psycho-sociocultural factors refers to a person’s ability to consciously or unconsciously interact with the social and cultural environment. They involve past experiences; the environment in which a person lives; the relationships with and support from others; the cultural norms; and the cognitive abilities, intellect, personality, and other psychological factors that make someone respond to their environment in their own unique way.
DEVELOPMENTAL FACTORS
Recognizing that both fetal and early childhood influences have long-term effects on a range of adult conditions, a body of research indicates that early-life events occurring before or around the time of birth or in the first years of life can play a role in influencing susceptibility to suicide.
While studies suggest that early-life factors may predispose to suicide, the mechanisms involved remain unknown. It is possible that they can produce changes in DNA methylation that subsequently influence an individual’s vulnerability to mental disorders and suicide. DNA methylation is one of several epigenetic mechanisms known to be influenced by the external environment and in turn affect transcriptional regulation and gene expression (Björkenstam et al., 2017).
Epidemiology shows that major risk factors for attempted suicide or suicide are childhood adversities such as sexual and/or physical abuse, neglect, caregiver psychopathology, and family or community violence. A recent study found that emotional abuse tripled the likelihood of attempting suicide, physical abuse almost doubled the chances, substance abuse in the family more than doubled the chances, and violent treatment of the mother almost quadrupled the chances (Geoffroy et al., 2017).
SOCIAL FACTORS
Having a network of supportive family, friends, and colleagues is important to a person’s self-esteem. Those with close social relationships cope better with stress and have better overall psychological and physical health. Social networks offer opportunities for sharing emotions and feeling connected. Isolation, however, can lead to feelings of depression and alienation, both of which can lead to suicidal thoughts and behaviors (Reiss & Dombeck, 2019b).
BULLYING AND SUICIDE
Bullying, along with other factors, increases the risk for suicide among youth. Bullying is defined as the intentional infliction of injury or discomfort on another person through words, physical contact, or in other ways, including the use of the Internet (cyberbullying). Over time and repeated attacks, bullying can lead to depression and anxiety, lowered self-esteem, or physical injury. It produces a mentality of helplessness, which contributes to suicidal thoughts and behavior. At-risk youth who are bullied, especially those who are already depressed, may view suicide as a rational solution to their problems.
The CDC (2019a) reports that youth who frequently bully others and youth who report being frequently bullied both are at increased risk for suicide-related behavior. Youth who bully others are at increased risk for substance use, academic problems, and experiencing violence later in adolescence and adulthood. Youth who bully others and are bullied themselves suffer the most serious consequences, are at greater risk for mental health and behavioral problems, and have the highest risk for suicide-related behavior of any groups involved in bullying.
Bullying is not confined to young people. Adult bullying exists as well. Adults mostly use verbal as opposed to physical bullying, and the goal is to gain power over another person and be dominant. Domestic violence is such an example, which often involves both verbal and physical bullying.
SOCIOCULTURAL FACTORS
Sociocultural factors are customs, lifestyles, and values that characterize a society. They include aesthetics, language, law, politics, religion, social organization, marital status, technology, material cultures, values, and attitudes.
Cultural groups can be supportive, creating feelings of belonging and serving as a safety net when members need support while experiencing problems or stressors. Being a member of a tightly united group can serve as a suicide deterrent.
The “down side” of group membership may be that it requires stressful obligations and high levels of commitment, leading a member of the group to adapt to the norms rather than think for themself. Some groups can be repressive and oppressive, which may contribute to suicidal thoughts and feelings. Some groups may even demand a person sacrifice him- or herself for the greater good (Reiss & Dombeck, 2019b).
Marriage is considered a cultural universal. Suicide occurs more frequently in people who are not married than those who are, and the risk of suicide is nearly two times greater in the nonmarried than the married. It is believed that marriage increases social integration and gives meaning to the life of the individual (Schreiber & Culpepper, 2019).
Occupation-related factors have an influence on suicidal behavior. Suicide may be greater in those who work in unskilled occupations. Among highly skilled workers, physicians have the highest suicide rate of any profession—more than twice that of the general population. The rate of suicide is greater in female physicians than the general population and is also greater in male physicians than the general population (Anderson, 2018).
Social norms dictate whether or not suicide is stigmatized. Many societies and religions, such as Christianity, ban suicide, considering it a taboo behavior or a sin. Others allow suicide. For example, some Islamic groups permit suicide as a means of martyrdom in war. The Hindu code of conduct makes suicide by fasting acceptable for incurable disease or as a response to great adversity. Judaism views suicide as acceptable only if one is being forced to commit an egregious sin such as murder (MPAC, 2019).
Adolescents generally have a high suicide attempt rate, and those who are involved in certain subcultures have an even higher risk. For instance, there is an increased incidence of self-harm activities (such as cutting) in the “Goth,” “emo,” and “punk” populations. Adolescents involved in repeated self-injury are up to eight times more likely to attempt suicide (Soreff, 2019).
It has been found that the rise in suicide and suicide attempts by adolescents correlates with the rise in electronic communication and social media. Social media and internet use contribute to poorer sleep quality, which in turn contributes to depressive symptoms in this age group. Constant connection to social media also impacts self-esteem that contributes to an increase in anxiety, as it is hard for young persons to compare their life and social connections to what they see others posting on social media (Twenge et al., 2019; McCarthy, 2019).
Adverse Life Events
An extensive body of sociodemographic and psychological autopsy studies finds that almost all persons who died by suicide had experienced at least one stressful life event (usually more than one) within the year prior to death. Specific events that increase the risk of suicide include:
- Death of a family member
- Interpersonal conflicts (family or relationships with third parties)
- Separation/divorce
- Rejection
- Humiliation
- Physical illness
- Chronic physical pain
- Unemployment
- Problems at work
- Financial problems
- Serious injury or attack
- Sexual or physical abuse
- Rape
- Personal loss
- Domestic violence
- Problems with the law
- Change of residence/moving
(Maniou et al., 2017)
Medications and Suicide
There are several medications that have been linked to suicidal behavior, for which the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requires a boxed warning (formerly known as a Black Box Warning).
- Antidepressants: The FDA warns that antidepressants increase the risk of suicidal thinking and suicidal behavior in children and adolescents with major depressive disorder and other psychiatric disorders, and that prescribing these medications requires vigilant monitoring following initiation. Controversy exists because these warnings have led to an increase in the rate of suicide following the decline in prescribing of antidepressants (Fornaro et al., 2019; FDA, 2018).
- Anticonvulsants: There have been reports over the past two decades of suicidal behavior after initiating anticonvulsant therapy such as lamotrigine gabapentin, carbamazepine, tiagabine, and oxcarbazepine. Providers are encouraged to exercise caution, carefully assessing behavioral comorbidities prior to initiation as well as frequent monitoring during the course of treatment (O’Rourke et al., 2019).
- Analgesics: Tramadol has been associated with a risk of self-harm for some people, including those with a history of depression or prone to addiction (Fookes, 2019; O’Rourke et al., 2019).
Factors Leading to Suicide According to Age
Suicide crosses all age groups in the United States, and suicide rates globally follow a standard pattern of increasing with age, with rates highest in people ages 70 years and older (IHME, 2018).
CHILDREN
Suicidal ideation occurs in prepubertal children, but suicide attempts and suicide deaths are rare. The number of young children who kill themselves has always been small, but it has been steadily increasing over time. For the very young (ages 5 to 11), suicide occurs in the United States at a rate of one every five days. These numbers, however, may not fully reflect reality, as failed attempts are not reported and some suicide deaths may be seen as accidents (Sheftall et al., 2016).
Parents often do not take talk of suicide by young children seriously because they believe kids do not understand the concept. By ages 5 to 7, however, children begin to understand death, though many do not grasp its irreversibility until about age 11 (Mink, 2018). Younger children who die by suicide are more likely to be of above-average intelligence, possibly exposing them to the developmental level of stress experienced by older children (Kennebeck & Bonin, 2017).
In a recent study of children ages 5 to 11 who died by suicide, the majority were black males who died at home by hanging, strangulation, or suffocation. Children were found to more often have had relationship problems with family members or friends. Very few left a suicide note, but nearly one third were found to have discussed suicide intent to another person before death. The children were found to more often have attention-deficit disorder with or without hyperactivity and less often experienced depression or dysthymia compared to early adolescents (ages 12 to 14) (Sheftall et al., 2016).
ADOLESCENTS
Adolescents have a relatively higher rate of suicide attempts than adults, and the majority who attempt suicide have a significant mental health disorder, usually depression (AACAP, 2018).
As adolescents develop their capacity for abstract and complex thinking, they are more capable of contemplating life circumstances, envisioning a hopeless future, considering suicide as a possible solution, and planning and executing a suicide attempt (Kennebeck & Bonin, 2017).
In a study of adolescents who attempted suicide, the weakest influence was direct social pressures that promote suicide, and the three strongest motivators were:
- Extreme emotional or psychological pain
- Desire to escape from one’s own thoughts, feelings, or actions
- Belief that things cannot get better or that one’s situation cannot improve
(Klonsky, 2019)
A systematic review of studies has found the high prevalence of adolescents consuming cannabis generates a large number of young people who are at risk for developing depression and suicidality (Gobbi et al., 2019).
CASE
JACOB
Avery, a registered nurse, was working the nightshift in the emergency department when an ambulance arrived with a young male patient who was discovered sitting inside his car with the engine running in a closed garage. When his mother found him, she called 911. On arrival, the patient was conscious but disoriented and was receiving high-dose oxygen via a facemask.
The young man’s name was Jacob, and he was 17 years old. His mother informed the staff that Jacob “has not been himself lately.” She went on to describe him as withdrawn and quiet, having problems sleeping, and without an appetite. He was no longer attending school functions because he felt “too tired.” He was also having problems with his girlfriend, expressing fear that she wanted to break up with him.
As Avery was drawing a blood sample, Jacob opened his eyes, pulled off the facemask, looked around, whispered, “Oh, no, I’m still here,” and began to cry.
(continues)
YOUNG ADULTS
Among 18- to 34-year-olds, there has been a 25% increase in suicide deaths since 2007, which is a greater increase in suicide deaths than among other age groups, except for children and adolescents. This age group has a number of risk factors that increase vulnerability to suicide:
- Impulse control centers in the brain are not fully developed until the mid-to-late-20s.
- They take more risks with sexual and drug-use behaviors compared to older adults.
- They make up the highest percentage of the U.S. military.
- They face high costs of postsecondary education and mounting student debt.
- The housing market is largely out of their reach.
- They lack the protective factors other age groups typically have, such as a supportive physical and social environment and financial safety nets.
- They are the age group with the greatest nonmedical and prescription use of opioids.
- They are beginning and growing in their chosen career.
- They grew up with a succession of negative events, including the 9/11 terror attacks, the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars, and the Great Recession.
- The impact of the rise of social media impacts the sense of their future prospects.
(TFAH, 2019; Anderson P., 2019)
MIDDLE-AGED ADULTS
Middle age (ages 35 to 64) is a time of maximum risk, with suicide rates increasing in both middle-aged men and women, although men are much more likely than women to die by suicide. Middle-aged men represent 19% of the U.S. population and account for 40% of suicide deaths (SPRC, 2019a).
The middle-age years are marked by heavy personal, social, and familial responsibilities and obligations, including growing and grown children and caring for aging parents. Issues such as unemployment, social disconnection, relationship breakdown, and job loss are sources of stress among this population (AFSP, 2019a).
Deaths from suicide as well as drugs and alcohol have risen steeply among white, middle-aged Americans. These are referred to as “deaths of despair” and are linked to declines in economic and social well-being among the white working class. Suicides have increased most sharply in rural communities where the loss of farming and manufacturing jobs have led to economic decline. Other factors include the lack of accessible and affordable mental health services and the availability of firearms (Weir, 2019).
OLDER ADULTS
Suicide rates are high among adults ages 65 and older, and in particular among older men. Men ages 85 and older have the highest rate of any group in the country. Suicide attempts by older adults are more likely to result in death because:
- Older adults plan more carefully and use more deadly methods.
- Older adults are less likely to be discovered and rescued.
- Physical frailty of older adults means they are less likely to recover from an attempt.
(SPRC, 2019b)
The main suicide risk factors for the older adult include:
- Grieving the death of a spouse (one of the most prevalent risk factors)
- Psychiatric and neurocognitive disorders
- Social isolation/exclusion
- Bereavement
- Transition in physical health
- Loss of independence
- Physical and psychological pain
- Cognitive impairment
(Conejero et al., 2018a ; SPRC, 2019b)
EUTHANASIA AND RATIONAL SUICIDE
The term euthanasia means “good death.” It is an umbrella term for taking measures to end the life of someone with unbearable suffering associated with terminal illness. When a physician provides the means to die by suicide but does not administer it, it is known as passive voluntary euthanasia in the form of physician-assisted suicide. When a second party fulfills a dying person’s request to be put to death, it is referred to as active voluntary euthanasia.
The question “Is suicide ever rational?” has been the subject of much debate. Most of the literature defining the term includes three characteristics: 1) the person has made a realistic assessment of his/her situation, 2) the person’s decision-making capacity is unimpaired by psychological illness or severe emotional distress, and 3) the motivation would be understandable to the majority of people in the community or social group.
Recently, more older adults are expressing the wish to end their lives as they see fit. The term rational suicide is usually applied to an adult with the ability to make a free choice and with sound decision-making skills. These individuals have what they consider an unrelenting, hopeless physical condition (terminal illness) and feel that their life is already complete. They express the wish to control the time, place, and manner in which they die.
Often older adults have poor social support systems and worry about being a burden to others. Some express the fear of spending a long period in a hospital or a nursing home. Other reasons given for wanting to die include:
- Loss of autonomy
- Loss of ability to engage in activities
- Loss of dignity
- Loss of bodily functions
- Inadequate pain control
- Financial implications of receiving treatment
In the United States, Oregon was the first state to legalize physician-assisted suicide in 1994. Since then, physician-assisted suicide has become legal in California, Colorado, Hawaii, Maine, New Jersey, Vermont, Washington, and the District of Columbia. Forty-one states consider assisted suicide illegal. Montana has legal physician-assisted suicide via Supreme Court ruling, as there is nothing in state law prohibiting a physician from honoring a terminally ill, mentally competent patient’s request.
(Brauser, 2015; DD, 2019)
WASHINGTON STATE DEATH WITH DIGNITY ACT
In 2008 Washington passed the Washington Death with Dignity Act, Initiative 1000. This act allows terminally ill adults who wish to end their life to request lethal doses of medication from medical and osteopathic physicians. These individuals must be Washington residents who are 18 years of age or older, capable of making and communicating healthcare decisions for themselves, and have been diagnosed with a terminal illness that will lead to death within six months.
Patients must first make an oral request to a physician, followed by a 15-day waiting period. A second oral request is then made, followed by a written request. There is then a 48-hour waiting period before picking up prescribed medications from a pharmacy.
The Death with Dignity Act has allowed adult residents to request lethal doses of medication from a physician. In 2017, medication was dispensed to 212 individuals. Prescriptions were written by 115 different physicians.
Of these 212 individuals, 196 are known to have died—164 died after ingesting the medication, 19 died without having ingested it, and the ingestion status is unknown for the remaining 13 people who died. For the remaining 16 persons not included among those known to have died, no death certificate was received by the Department of Health that indicated death had occurred.
Death certificates for the 196 persons who died revealed that the youngest was 33 and the oldest 98 years of age, 94% were white, 47% were married, 75% had some college education, and 72% had cancer.
Of the 196 individuals in 2017 who died, After Death Reports were provided for 186 of them, indicating that 90% reported concerns about loss of autonomy, 73% reported concerns about the ability to participate in activities that make life enjoyable, and 73% were concerned over the loss of dignity.
Of the 164 who died following ingestion of the medication, 88% died at home and 88% were enrolled in hospice care when medication was ingested.
(WADOH, 2018)
Suicide Risk among Specific Populations
Although suicide affects all groups of the population, the risk and protective factors for suicide may differ. The following summarizes risk and protective factors among specific populations.
PERSONS WITH DEMENTIA
Recent study findings suggest that late-stage dementia could protect against suicidal ideation and suicide attempts. On the other hand, the risk of suicide is higher during the early phase of cognitive decline. The following factors may contribute to increasing the suicide rate in early dementia include:
- Awareness of cognitive decline and feelings of being a burden to significant others
- Anticipation of future loss of autonomy
- An increased prevalence of comorbid mood and adjustment disorders
- Presence of still good cognitive functions in the early stage that allow the person to plan and complete a suicidal act
- Deficits in executive functions, decision-making, and inhibition process
Other findings indicate that suicide attempts or deaths in patients with early-stage Alzheimer’s disease could be a consequence of amyloid burden through its association with depressive symptoms that are frequently observed in patients with early-stage dementia. Amyloid burden is a potential risk for suicide through its effects on neurobiological pathways such as serotonergic dysregulation, dysfunctional stress response, and brain inflammation (Conejero et al., 2018b).
ADULTS WITH LEARNING DISABILITIES
The prevalence of lifetime suicide attempts among those with a learning disability, such as dyslexia, is much higher than those without a learning disability. Adults with a learning disability had nearly double the odds of having ever attempted suicide, even after adjusting for childhood adversities, mental illness, addiction history, and sociodemographics (Fuller-Thomson et al., 2018).
CAREGIVERS
As the population in the United States ages, more people require care provided by family members in managing all aspects of daily living. The risk to the health and well-being of caregivers is well documented. They report high levels of stress and have higher rates of depression and anxiety as well as poorer physical health than noncaregivers. Caregivers are often affected by a wide range of stressors, including exposure to domestic violence, financial difficulties, or stressful life events. This may be more marked among those caring for someone with dementia. Research has found that one fourth of caregivers looking after family members with dementia contemplated suicide more than once in the prior year, and almost a third said they were likely to attempt suicide in the future (Joling et al., 2017; Rosato et al., 2019).
MILITARY SERVICE PERSONNEL
Suicide is the second leading cause of death among U.S. military personnel. A recent study asked a group of active-duty soldiers why they tried to kill themselves, and out of the 33 reasons they had to choose from, all of the soldiers included a desire to end intense emotional distress (MSRC, 2019).
Experiencing child abuse, being sexually victimized, and exhibiting suicidal behavior before enlistment are significant risk factors for service members and veterans, making them more vulnerable to suicidal behavior when coping with combat and multiple deployments.
Military personnel reporting child abuse as children have been found to be three to eight times more likely to report suicidal behavior. Sexual trauma of any type increases the risk for suicidal behavior. Men who have experienced sexual trauma are less likely to seek mental health care than females, as they may see it as a threat to their masculinity, a strong predictor of suicide attempts in military personnel. Service members who attempted suicide before joining the military are six times more likely to attempt suicide after joining the military (APA, 2019a).
A number of psychosocial factors are associated with suicide risk in the military, including relationship problems, administrative/legal issues, and workplace difficulties. Medical conditions that are associated with an increased risk for suicide among military personnel include traumatic brain injury, chronic pain, and sleep disorders (USUCDP, 2019).
Suicide among women in the military has increased at twice the rate of male service members. The primary reason is sexual trauma, particularly incidences of harassment and rape while stationed overseas. An estimated one in four military women are victims of sexual trauma. This number, however, is believed to be low due to the stigma and possible consequences associated with reporting. Sexual trauma combined with combat stress can result in a higher risk of dying by suicide (Gorn, 2019).
MILITARY VETERANS
There is strong evidence that among veterans who experienced combat trauma, the highest suicide risk has been observed in those who were wounded multiple times and/or were hospitalized as a result of being wounded.
Studies that looked specifically at combat-related PTSD found that the most significant predictor of both suicide attempts and the preoccupation with thoughts of suicide is combat-related guilt about acts committed during the times of war. Those with only some PTSD symptoms have been found to report hopelessness or suicidal ideation three times more often than those without PTSD (VA, 2019).
Suicide Protective Factors
Although there are many risk factors for suicide, there are also factors that protect people from making an attempt or dying by suicide. These protective factors are both personal and environmental.
Personal protective factors include:
- Values, attitudes, and norms that prohibit suicide, such as strong beliefs about the meaning and value of life
- Strong problem-solving skills
- Social skills, including conflict resolution and nonviolent ways of handling disputes
- Good health and access to mental and physical healthcare
- Strong connections to friends and family as well as supportive significant others
- Cultural, religious, or spiritual beliefs that discourage suicide
- A healthy fear of risky behaviors and pain
- Optimism about the future and reasons for living
- Sobriety
- Medical compliance and a sense of the importance of health and wellness
- Good impulse control
- A strong sense of self-esteem or self-worth
- A sense of personal control or determination
- Strong coping skills and resiliency
- Being married or a parent
- Being pregnant (although pregnancy and motherhood has been studied as a protective factor, suicide remains a leading cause of maternal death in industrialized countries and vigilance in assessing for ante- and postpartum depression and anxiety must be strongly considered)
(Weber et al., 2019)
External/environmental protective factors include:
- Opportunities to participate in and contribute to school or community projects and activities
- A reasonably safe and stable environment
- Financial security
- Responsibilities and duties to others
- Owning a pet
- Restricted access to lethal means
(CDC, 2019b; SPRC, 2019c; WMU, 2019)